There's been a lot of debate recently about the latest issues of
Catwoman and
Red Hood and the Outlaws. Many posts have already been written including
this one on
Comics Alliance and the
counter-argument from
Panels on Pages.
So, why bother writing another one? Because I'd like to tackle this the way I view it, from an artist's perspective. I see a lot of people in comics - not just print, webcomics also - making the assumption that drawing a "sexually liberated woman" involves focusing primarily on her more... ahem... ample assets.
In other words, her tits and her ass.
Hey, don't get me wrong, I love a well drawn woman. Yeah, I'm a woman myself, but that doesn't mean I don't appreciate lovely ladies. The female body is a true work of art. And, I enjoy seeing striking female forms in comics. I'm the proud owner of Adam Hughes'
Cover Run, Alex Ross'
Rough Justice, and Jim Lee's
Icons. I'll admit it, I love how these men draw women. It was
Terry Moore's beautiful renditions of realistic women that drew me to comics in the
first place. And I can't wait for
Amanda Conner's art book to come out.
So, what's wrong with showing sexy women in comics?
Nothing. As long as you do it right.
You see, part of what makes a woman beautiful - a great part of it, in fact - is her
face. Her face is where her emotions and her personality live. It's what makes her
human and not just a sex object. But, it's not enough to just show us her face, you need to put some action in there, some sense of feeling. If you want me to believe that your character truly is a "sexually liberated woman" then I want to see her
enjoying what she's doing. 'Cause that's the point! A woman who is comfortable in her sexuality
enjoys the rise she gets out of people. It's part of the appeal to her. She looks good, she knows she looks good, and she wants others to notice. She smiles. She smirks. She flirts and gives knowing glances. She focuses her attention on the people she desires. She ignores those who she deems unworthy. It's this knowledge of her sexuality that makes her powerful. It's that power... that makes her liberated.
She's a living, breathing individual with her own unique personality.
And, we get glimpses of her personality from her face.
For example, let's look at a print of Catwoman by Amanda Conner. Before we look at the whole print, let's focus on what many people believe is the sole key to a sexy female character - her breasts.
Yes, we know it's Catwoman by the outfit - the clawed gloves and whip make it quite clear. And yes, she has a lovely chest - the little bit of peek-a-boo with the bra is a nice touch. But that's it. Her playful personality - one of the things that I, personally, have always found appealing about Catwoman - is missing.
Here's the whole picture.
Now
that's the Catwoman I know and love. You can almost hear her saying, "Fine. You want them, Bat-beau? Come and get 'em." Her face shows us that she's not about to let a guy dressed as a giant bat ruin
her fun. She's still in control of the situation. She knows Batman's buttons and oh, is she going to have fun pushing them!
I didn't get any sense of that from the cropped version focusing on just her chest. For all we know, she could have looked annoyed, frightened, depressed... hell, even ill. True, word balloons may have helped, but remember, there's no vocal tone in just text. It's not like spoken dialog where we can hear hints of annoyance, disgust, or flirtation. This is why it's important for us artists to try to use as many cues as possible to covey a panel's emotions properly. It's also why we fail fairly often. It's not an easy task, especially when we're tying to keep our pages interesting visually.
Look, there's nothing wrong with sexy women in comics. Hell, many of us women love seeing them too. But, if you're going to do it - and fellow webcomic creators, I'm looking at you as well - please at least have the decency to do it right. Show us all of her. Her face, her personality. Make her live and breathe. Give us the chance to love her for who she
is, not just her cup size.
"A woman is sometimes fugitive, irrational, indeterminable, illogical and contradictory. A great deal of forbearance ought to be shown her, and a good deal of prudence exercised with regard to her, for she may bring about innumerable evils without knowing it. Capable of all kinds of devotion, and of all kinds of treason, monster incomprehensible, raised to the second power, she is at once the delight and the terror of man."
-- Henri Frederic Amiel