Ugh! My brain's fried this week. All I can think about is the upcoming trip to visit Matt's family. We're leaving Thursday morning and as a result, I think my mind has shut down for the week. All it wants to do is read and wander off down strange, new paths. Not the useful, comic related paths I want it to.
Unfortunately - or perhaps fortunately, depending on how you look at it - I've learned that letting my brain get this out of its system leads to a much faster return to comic-ing. Trying to fight it... not so much.
So, it looks like I'll be spending the next few days letting my mind get into mischief. I'll try to coax it back down the CN:H path with some notebook paper next week. While this brings work on the comic pages to a halt, it does tend to lead to fixing little hiccups in the story line and, in my opinion, a slightly stronger plot. So, perhaps it's for the best.
One of the things my mind's been turning over is this disconnect I've run across a few times online and at cons... namely people who really have no clue about how to do something yet, believe they excel at doing said thing. Meanwhile, on the flip side, you have people who excel at a skill believing that they are, in fact, inadequate.
Personally, as someone who often lacks confidence despite others' belief that I 'know my stuff,' I always assumed the blustering of the one group led to these feelings in the other. 'If that guy over there says he's doing so well, then he must be. I don't like his work, I see it as clumsy and unskilled, but if he's doing well then logic states that people must like his work more than mine. After all, I don't feel I have anything to brag about. Thereby, it must be my process which is flawed. Which means, my work is inadequate.'
Seriously, my brain does this whenever I run across someone praising their work and abilities to the heavens. Now, before anyone believes this leads me down a road of self-pity, let's get one thing straight here... it doesn't. While it generates feelings of self doubt, it also creates confusion and, oddly enough, anger. Not at myself, but at the person who's parading about like a peacock. Especially if that person is basing their bragging on their ability to give out false information. Maybe it's the fact that I worked in the library field for a while and had to deal with patrons who believed that they already know all the answers (If that's the case, then why ask in the fist place?) and yet everything they know is inaccurate... yeah. Have you ever tried to teach someone who's like that? Try it sometime.
Anyway, I knew I wasn't the only artist who feels this way, so I figured it must be fairly normal. The other side of the coin - those who really have no clue who believe they're excelling anyway... those people I never got. Am I missing something here?
Turns out, there's a term for it. It's called the Dunning–Kruger effect, after Justin Kruger and David Dunning. According to
Wikipedia it's...
...a cognitive bias in which unskilled people make poor decisions and reach erroneous conclusions, but their incompetence denies them the meta-cognitive ability to realize their mistakes. The unskilled therefore suffer from illusory superiority, rating their own ability as above average, much higher than it actually is, while the highly skilled underrate their abilities, suffering from illusory inferiority. This leads to the situation in which less competent people rate their own ability higher than more competent people. It also explains why actual competence may weaken self-confidence. Competent individuals falsely assume that others have an equivalent understanding.
It goes on to say that for any skill or knowledge in question, those who are in the grips of the Dunning-Kruger effect and are incompetent will...
1. tend to overestimate their own level of skill;
2. fail to recognize genuine skill in others;
3. fail to recognize the extremity of their inadequacy;
4. recognize and acknowledge their own previous lack of skill, if they can be trained to substantially improve.
This could explain a lot. Such as the person who can't get their comic off the ground yet, insists on telling you how you're running your comic wrong. Or, the person who can't write worth a damn who corners you at a con for over an hour, lecturing you on how to write using tactics you learned in high school. Or, you yourself feeling like an ineffective lump despite being able to moderately make things work.
I can see a good and bad effect of each side of this. If you feel overconfident in your abilities and that confidence is hard to shatter, then you probably feel pretty good about yourself quite often. And everyone wants to feel good about themselves, right? Unfortunately, on the downside, if you do always feel that you're the expert, then when will you ever be motivate to actually learn and improve? When will you ever take the time to evaluate your knowledge and perhaps discover that some of the facts you know are actually false? Chances are good you probably won't. Why bother? You're the expert, after all.
If you feel inadequate in your knowledge and abilities, chances are good you'll be motivated to learn and improve. If you feel you're a hideous author and yet, you want to be like the writers you admire, you're likely to practice, take courses, and learn the theory behind the craft. And, you will improve. Unfortunately, chances are good that you will still feel inadequate. No matter how much you accomplish, you will always see yet another goal off in the distance. While this is great for fostering a desire for life-long learning, it can easily mess with your self-esteem. And while the overconfident are perfectly capable of writing off your abilities as bunk (despite the fact that those said abilities should be a clear sign that they themselves fail to measure up) you will be unable to dismiss their claims as easily. You may even find yourself wondering if, in fact, they're right and you're wrong.
Either way, it sucks. I guess your best bet is, if you find yourself slipping into either of these mindsets, to recognize the pattern and break out of it. Think you're an expert? Then try doing something that's in your "realm of expertise" and yet outside of your comfort zone. And, if you fail at it, own your failure instead of blaming it on someone else. If you feel you're inadequate, take stock of what you can do and how well you do it. Recognize that it took time and effort to reach that level and that you have a right to be pleased with the results.
Or, you could always just knock the person who's annoying the hell out of you down an open manhole and into the sewer. Yeah, I like that idea. Maybe I'll try that this year at AC.
"Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge."
-- Charles Darwin